As a standout on the St. Clair women's volleyball team in the mid-1980s, Beth Brannagan was named to the CCAA all-Canadian team on two occasions (1986-87 and 1987-88).

Brannagan was also selected to the OCAA league all-star team twice and in 1987-88 she was named St. Clair's Female Athlete of theYear.

Her outstanding career was recognized in 2000, when she was included on the OCAA Women's Volleyball All-Millennium team.