Anthony Notarianni spent three seasons with the Mohawk Mountaineers and during his tenure was named OCAA league all-star (1991, 1992). Notarianni found success in the OCAA post-season, earning an OCAA silver medal in both the 1990 and 1992 seasons.

In his final season as a Mountaineer, Notarianni also received the CCAA all-Canadian Award (1993).

Mohawk named Notarianni its MVP in two seasons (1992, 1993). He has also named an Outstanding Male Athlete by Mohawk College.

Notarianni was named a member of the OCAA Men's Soccer All-Millennium Team.